5 Best Refrigerators with Ice Makers [In 2025]

Have you ever reached for a cold drink on a hot day only to find your ice tray empty? Or hosted a gathering where you constantly had to refill ice trays to keep up with demand? If these scenarios sound familiar, it might be time to consider a refrigerator with a built-in ice maker. These convenient appliances can transform your kitchen experience by providing a steady supply of ice without the hassle of manual filling and freezing.

In today’s market, refrigerators with ice makers have become increasingly popular, and for good reason. They offer convenience, save time, and ensure you always have ice on hand when you need it. But with so many options available, how do you choose the right one for your home?

In this comprehensive guide, I’ll walk you through everything you need to know about refrigerators with ice makers, including the top 5 models currently on the market. We’ll explore their features, pros and cons, and help you determine which one might be the perfect fit for your kitchen and lifestyle.

Top 5 Refrigerators with Ice Makers in 2025

Now, let’s dive into the details of our top five refrigerators with ice makers. Each model offers unique features and benefits, catering to different preferences and needs.

Commercial Cool 20 Cu. Ft. Top Mount Refrigerator with Ice Maker

The Commercial Cool 20 Cu. Ft. Top Mount Refrigerator combines generous storage space with efficient performance. This stainless-look appliance offers a traditional top freezer design with modern features, including an automatic ice maker that can produce up to 3.5 pounds of ice daily.

With dimensions of 32.9″D x 29.5″W x 66.7″H, this refrigerator fits comfortably in most kitchen spaces while providing ample storage for a family’s needs. The 20 cubic feet capacity is well-distributed between the refrigerator and freezer compartments.

Pros and Cons

Pros:

• Generous 20 cu. ft. capacity suitable for families
• Energy Star certified for reduced power consumption
• Independent temperature controls for refrigerator and freezer sections
• Frost-free design eliminates manual defrosting
• Ice maker produces approximately 3.5 lbs of ice daily
• Stainless-look finish adds a modern touch to kitchens
• Quiet operation as reported by users

Cons:

• Some users report the freezer occasionally gets too cold and may need defrosting about twice a year
• Limited customization options for shelf arrangement compared to higher-end models
• Basic features compared to more premium options

Who Should Buy This Model?

The Commercial Cool refrigerator is ideal for:

• Families needing substantial storage space
• Budget-conscious shoppers wanting essential features without premium pricing
• Those who prefer a traditional top-freezer configuration
• Households that value energy efficiency
• Anyone wanting reliable ice production without excessive features

As one satisfied customer mentioned, “Love this little powerhouse,” noting its reliability and functionality, particularly in situations where ready access to cold drinks and ice is important. This refrigerator offers practicality and performance at a reasonable price point.

Kenmore 33 in. 20.4 cu. ft Stainless Steel Refrigerator with Ice Maker

The Kenmore 33 in. 20.4 cu. ft refrigerator combines sleek design with practical features. Its fingerprint-resistant stainless steel finish gives it a premium look while being family-friendly. Measuring 30.75″D x 32.68″W x 66.38″H, this refrigerator offers a slightly wider profile but similar overall capacity to the Commercial Cool model.

What sets this Kenmore apart is its thoughtful interior organization with adjustable full-width glass shelving and specialized storage compartments. The built-in ice maker produces up to 3 pounds of crescent-shaped ice daily, suitable for most household needs.

Pros and Cons

Pros:

• Fingerprint-resistant stainless steel finish stays cleaner longer
• Full-width adjustable glass shelves for customized storage
• Humidity-controlled crisper drawers for extended produce freshness
• Clear dairy compartment maintains ideal butter and cheese temperatures
• Gallon-sized door bins maximize storage efficiency
• Factory-installed ice maker produces up to 3 lbs of ice daily
• ENERGY STAR certified for lower operating costs

Cons:

• Slightly more expensive than basic models
• Some users reported minor shipping damage (dents/dings)
• Ice production slightly less than some competitors (3 lbs vs. 3.5 lbs)
• Requires 33-inch width space, which may be challenging in smaller kitchens

Who Should Buy This Model?

The Kenmore stainless steel refrigerator is perfect for:

• Those who value aesthetics alongside functionality
• Families who need versatile storage options
• Households that prioritize produce freshness
• People who want a clean-looking appliance with minimal fingerprint cleaning
• Anyone looking for a balance of premium features without the highest-end price tag

One customer noted, “I was also pleasantly surprised to see that the built-in ice maker didn’t take up too much space and that the freezer had plenty of room.” This highlights the Kenmore’s efficient use of space despite including an ice maker – a common concern when adding this feature.

BLACK+DECKER 20.1 Cu. Ft. Top Mount Refrigerator with Ice Maker

The BLACK+DECKER 20.1 Cu. Ft. refrigerator offers a classic black finish that makes a bold statement in any kitchen. With dimensions of 31.1″D x 29.5″W x 66.6″H, this model features a traditional top-freezer design with modern conveniences.

This refrigerator includes an ice maker with probe sensor technology that produces approximately 3.5 pounds of ice daily. The frost-free design and inverter compressor provide maintenance-free operation and energy efficiency.

Pros and Cons

Pros:

• Sleek black finish offers an alternative to stainless steel or white
• Spacious 20.1 cu. ft. capacity accommodates family needs
• Ice maker with probe sensor for consistent ice production
• Adjustable temperature control for both refrigerator and freezer
• Frost-free design eliminates manual defrosting
• Inverter compressor ensures energy efficiency and quiet operation
• ENERGY STAR certified for lower utility bills

Cons:

• Black finish may show dust more readily than other colors
• Some users mentioned delivery issues (though not product-related)
• Less detailed internal organization compared to premium models
• Limited feedback on long-term reliability due to newer model status

Who Should Buy This Model?

The BLACK+DECKER black refrigerator is excellent for:

• Those who prefer black appliances to match kitchen decor
• Households seeking quiet operation (inverter compressor)
• Budget-conscious shoppers who don’t want to sacrifice quality
• People who value energy efficiency
• Those who want reliable ice production without complexity

As one customer reported, “Keeps everything extremely cold at mid setting, 4, and is whisper quiet. All I hear is a few clicks at night and mostly don’t notice that.” This quietness can be a significant advantage, especially in open-concept homes or when the refrigerator is near living spaces.

Kenmore 33 in. 20.4 cu. ft White Refrigerator with Ice Maker

The Kenmore 33 in. white refrigerator shares the same dimensions and core features as its stainless steel counterpart (30.75″D x 32.68″W x 66.38″H) but offers a classic white finish that works well in traditional kitchens. This model includes all the practical internal features that make the Kenmore line popular, including adjustable glass shelving and humidity-controlled crispers.

The built-in ice maker produces up to 3 pounds of crescent-shaped ice daily, matching the stainless steel version’s capability. The white exterior provides a clean, bright appearance that can help smaller kitchens feel more spacious.

Pros and Cons

Pros:

• Classic white finish fits with various kitchen styles
• Full-width adjustable glass shelves for versatile storage
• Humidity-controlled crisper drawers maintain produce freshness
• Clear dairy compartment for butter and spreads
• Gallon-sized door bins in both refrigerator and freezer
• Factory-installed ice maker produces up to 3 lbs of ice daily
• ENERGY STAR certified for reduced energy consumption

Cons:

• White finish may show dirt or discoloration over time
• Some users mentioned limited lighting in the freezer section
• Ice production slightly lower than some competitors
• Similar price point to stainless steel despite traditionally lower costs for white appliances

Who Should Buy This Model?

The Kenmore white refrigerator is ideal for:

• Those with traditional or country-style kitchens
• People who prefer bright, clean-looking appliances
• Households that value produce freshness with humidity controls
• Families needing versatile storage options
• Anyone wanting reliable ice production with proven technology

One customer commented, “The storage space is incredible, easily accommodating everything I need,” highlighting the effective use of the 20.4 cubic foot capacity. Another noted, “The shelves are fully adjustable which is so convenient for customizing exactly what you want to put in your fridge and how you’d like it stored,” emphasizing the practical flexibility of this model.

BLACK+DECKER 16 Cu. Ft. French Door Refrigerator with Built-in Ice Maker

The BLACK+DECKER 16 Cu. Ft. French Door refrigerator offers a more premium design in a slightly smaller package. With dimensions of 29″D x 28.3″W x 69.9″H, this model features elegant French doors for the refrigerator section and a bottom freezer drawer, all in a sophisticated black finish.

Despite its smaller 16 cubic foot total capacity, this refrigerator maximizes usable space with its efficient French door design. The refrigerator section provides 11.15 cu. ft. while the freezer offers 5.06 cu. ft. capacity, including the ice maker that produces up to 3.5 pounds of ice daily.

Pros and Cons

Pros:

• Modern French door design adds elegance to any kitchen
• Digital temperature control for precise climate management
• Bottom freezer drawer provides efficient organization
• Ice maker produces up to 3.5 lbs of ice daily
• Compact footprint (28.3″ width) fits in smaller spaces
• Frost-free operation eliminates manual defrosting
• ENERGY STAR certified for energy efficiency

Cons:

• Smaller 16 cu. ft. total capacity may not suit larger families
• Premium design typically comes with a higher price point
• Limited customer feedback on long-term performance
• Black finish may show fingerprints and dust more readily

Who Should Buy This Model?

The BLACK+DECKER French Door refrigerator is perfect for:

• Those with space constraints but wanting premium features
• Design-conscious consumers who value aesthetics
• Smaller households that don’t need maximum capacity
• People who prefer the convenience of French doors and bottom freezer
• Anyone wanting ice maker functionality in a more compact appliance

A customer succinctly noted it “is a functional garage freezer, and being black it blends well with the utility cabinets.” This highlights the versatility of this model – while designed for kitchen use, its sleek appearance and efficient size make it suitable for secondary locations like garages or basement kitchens.

Why an Ice Maker is an Essential Refrigerator Feature

Before diving into the specific models, let’s talk about why an ice maker is such a valuable feature in a modern refrigerator. Is it really worth prioritizing this feature when shopping for a new appliance?

Benefits of Built-in Ice Makers

Having a built-in ice maker in your refrigerator offers numerous advantages over traditional ice trays:

1. Convenience: No more filling, spilling, and refilling ice trays. Your refrigerator automatically produces ice for you.
2. Consistent Supply: You’ll always have ice available when you need it, whether for everyday use or when entertaining guests.
3. Space Efficiency: Built-in ice makers typically use space more efficiently than storing multiple ice trays.
4. Quality Ice: Many ice makers produce uniform, clean ice cubes that are consistent in size and shape.
5. Time-Saving: The automated process saves you time and the minor frustration of dealing with stubborn ice trays.

As one user shared about the Commercial Cool model, “A small thing but a game changer, improved some very basic elements of quality of life dramatically.” This sentiment captures how seemingly simple features like an ice maker can significantly enhance your daily experience.

How Much Ice Can You Expect Daily?

Most residential refrigerator ice makers produce between 3 to 5 pounds of ice per day. For context, that’s approximately 130-170 standard ice cubes daily. This output is sufficient for most households’ everyday needs, from cooling beverages to small gatherings.

All five refrigerators we’re reviewing today produce approximately 3.5 pounds of ice per day, which translates to around 150 ice cubes. This capacity is perfect for average family use and even small gatherings. However, it’s worth noting that production rates can vary based on freezer temperature and usage patterns.

Key Factors to Consider When Choosing a Refrigerator with Ice Maker

Finding the right refrigerator with an ice maker involves more than just comparing ice production rates. Here are some crucial factors to keep in mind during your search:

Capacity and Storage Space

The overall capacity of your refrigerator determines how much food and beverages you can store. For families, larger capacities (18-25 cubic feet) are generally recommended, while smaller households might be fine with less.

Beyond the total cubic footage, consider how the interior space is organized:

• Does it have adjustable shelving?
• Are there specialized compartments for different types of food?
• How much door storage is available?

The models we’re reviewing range from 16 to 20.4 cubic feet, catering to different household sizes and storage needs.

Energy Efficiency

Energy-efficient refrigerators not only help the environment but also save you money on electricity bills in the long run. Look for the ENERGY STAR certification, which indicates that the appliance meets strict energy efficiency guidelines set by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency.

All five refrigerators in our list are ENERGY STAR certified, highlighting manufacturers’ commitment to energy conservation without sacrificing performance.

Ice Production Rate

Consider how much ice your household typically uses. If you frequently entertain or have a large family that consumes many cold beverages, you’ll want a model with a higher ice production rate.

As mentioned earlier, our selected models produce around 3.5 pounds of ice daily, which suits most households’ needs. If you require more, you might need to consider refrigerators with dual ice makers or standalone ice machines.

Design and Configuration

Refrigerators come in various configurations, each with its own advantages:

• Top Freezer: Traditional design with the freezer on top; typically more affordable and energy-efficient.
• Bottom Freezer: Places fresh food at eye level with the freezer below; often more convenient for accessing frequently used items.
• French Door: Features two side-by-side doors for the refrigerator section with a bottom freezer; provides wide shelves and good organization options.
• Side-by-Side: The refrigerator and freezer sections run the full height of the appliance side by side; offers good organizational options but typically narrower shelves.

In our selection, we cover top freezer models and a French door design to give you options based on your preference and kitchen layout.

Additional Features Worth Having

Beyond the ice maker, consider these valuable features:

• Frost-Free Operation: Eliminates the need for manual defrosting.
• Adjustable Temperature Controls: Allows fine-tuning of cooling for different food types.
• Humidity-Controlled Crispers: Helps keep produce fresher for longer.
• Fingerprint-Resistant Finish: Maintains a clean appearance with less cleaning.
• Adjustable Shelving: Provides flexibility for storing items of various sizes.

These features can significantly enhance your refrigerator experience and food preservation capabilities.

Comparing the Top Ice Maker Refrigerators

To help you make an informed decision, let’s compare these five refrigerators across some key metrics:

Ice Production Capacity

All five models offer similar ice production capabilities, ranging from 3 to 3.5 pounds daily:

• Commercial Cool: 3.5 lbs/day
• Kenmore (both colors): 3 lbs/day
• BLACK+DECKER Top Mount: 3.5 lbs/day
• BLACK+DECKER French Door: 3.5 lbs/day

For perspective, a standard ice cube tray produces about 12 cubes, with each weighing roughly 0.8 ounces. This means these refrigerators can produce approximately 130-150 ice cubes daily – sufficient for most household needs but potentially limiting for frequent entertainers or large families with heavy ice usage.

Energy Efficiency Ratings

Energy efficiency impacts both your utility bills and environmental footprint. All models in our selection are ENERGY STAR certified, indicating they meet strict energy efficiency guidelines established by the EPA.

The inverter compressor in the BLACK+DECKER models may provide additional efficiency benefits through variable speed operation that adjusts to cooling demands rather than simply turning on and off. This technology typically results in steadier temperatures and quieter operation as well.

While specific annual energy consumption figures weren’t provided, ENERGY STAR certification typically indicates at least 10% greater efficiency than non-certified models. For a refrigerator, this can translate to $35-$70 in annual energy savings, depending on local electricity rates.

Value for Money

Value encompasses more than just price – it’s about what you get for your investment:

• The Commercial Cool and BLACK+DECKER Top Mount models offer excellent value in the standard top-freezer category, providing reliable performance and ice making without premium pricing.
• The Kenmore models (both stainless steel and white) add value through thoughtful organizational features like humidity-controlled crispers and adjustable glass shelving, justifying their slightly higher price point.
• The BLACK+DECKER French Door model, despite its smaller capacity, offers value through its premium design and space efficiency, making it ideal for those who prioritize style and function in smaller kitchens.

Remember that long-term reliability also factors into value. While we don’t have extensive longevity data on these specific models, both Kenmore and BLACK+DECKER have established reputations in home appliances.

Installation and Maintenance Tips for Ice Maker Refrigerators

Proper installation and maintenance are crucial for optimal performance and longevity of your refrigerator with ice maker.

Proper Installation Guidelines

Follow these steps for successful installation:

1. Allow settling time: After delivery, let your refrigerator stand upright for 24 hours before plugging it in. This allows refrigerant and oil to settle properly after transportation.
2. Ensure proper clearance: Maintain at least 1-2 inches of space around the sides and back of your refrigerator for proper air circulation. This prevents overheating and maintains efficiency.
3. Level the unit: Use adjustable feet to ensure your refrigerator is perfectly level. This is critical for proper door sealing and ice maker function.
4. Connect to water supply: For the ice maker to function, you’ll need a connection to your home’s water supply. Consider using a refrigerator installation kit with copper or flexible stainless steel tubing. If you’re not comfortable with plumbing connections, hiring a professional installer is recommended.
5. Use surge protection: As one customer wisely suggested, “Here on Amazon you can buy surge protectors for refrigerators.” These devices protect your investment from power fluctuations.

Routine Maintenance for Optimal Ice Production

Keep your ice maker performing optimally with these maintenance tips:

1. Replace water filters: If your model has a water filtration system, follow manufacturer guidelines for replacement schedules (typically every 6 months).
2. Clean the ice bin regularly: Remove and wash the ice storage bin monthly to prevent odor transfer and buildup.
3. Check water line connections: Periodically inspect for leaks or kinks in the water supply line.
4. Monitor ice quality: Changes in ice appearance, taste, or smell could indicate filter replacement or cleaning is needed.
5. Clear the dispenser path: For models with through-door dispensers, regularly clean the chute to prevent blockages.

Troubleshooting Common Ice Maker Issues

Even the best ice makers may occasionally need troubleshooting:

1. Ice maker not producing: Check that the water supply is connected and turned on, the freezer temperature is cold enough (0°F/-18°C or colder), and that the ice maker mechanism isn’t jammed.
2. Slow ice production: Ensure the freezer temperature is properly set. Too warm settings slow ice production significantly.
3. Strange-tasting ice: Replace the water filter and clean the ice bin. If problems persist, check your home’s water quality.
4. Clumping ice: This typically indicates temperature fluctuations. Ensure the freezer door seals properly and isn’t opened excessively.
5. Noise during ice production: Some noise is normal during the ice-making cycle, but excessive noise could indicate mechanical issues requiring service.

Is a Refrigerator with Ice Maker Worth the Investment?

When deciding whether to prioritize an ice maker in your next refrigerator purchase, consider both the conveniences and potential drawbacks.

Cost vs. Convenience Analysis

Refrigerators with built-in ice makers typically cost $100-300 more than comparable models without this feature. Is this premium justified?

For many households, the convenience factor alone makes the additional cost worthwhile:

• No more filling, spilling, and forgetting to refill ice trays
• Always having ice available for guests without preparation
• Consistent ice cube size and quality
• Time savings over the appliance’s lifetime

As one user eloquently put it, the ice maker was “a small thing but a game changer, improved some very basic elements of quality of life dramatically.” This sentiment captures how seemingly minor conveniences can significantly enhance daily living.

Long-term Savings Potential

Beyond convenience, consider these potential savings:

1. Reduced food waste: Many refrigerators with ice makers also feature improved temperature management and food preservation features, potentially reducing spoilage.
2. Energy efficiency: ENERGY STAR certified models save on utility bills over their lifetime, often offsetting the higher initial purchase price.
3. Home value: Updated kitchen appliances with modern features like ice makers can contribute to home resale value.
4. Bottled water alternatives: Having readily available ice encourages using tap water in reusable bottles rather than purchasing bottled water, creating both environmental and financial benefits.

For most households, the combination of convenience, quality of life improvement, and potential long-term savings makes refrigerators with ice makers a worthwhile investment.

Frequently Asked Questions

How much water does a refrigerator ice maker use?

 Refrigerator ice makers use surprisingly little water—approximately 3 gallons to produce 10 pounds of ice. For the models we’ve reviewed producing 3-3.5 pounds daily, that translates to roughly 1 gallon of water daily. This minimal consumption makes ice makers an efficient choice compared to purchasing bagged ice.

Can I add an ice maker to my existing refrigerator? 

While some refrigerators are “ice maker ready” with the necessary connections and space, adding an aftermarket ice maker to a standard refrigerator is typically not recommended. The process requires professional installation, may void warranties, and often delivers suboptimal results. If having an ice maker is important, it’s generally better to purchase a refrigerator with this feature built in.

How long do built-in ice makers typically last? 

With proper maintenance, built-in ice makers should last 3-10 years, though this varies by model and usage patterns. Regular cleaning and ensuring proper water quality (using filters when needed) can significantly extend the lifespan of your ice maker.

Do ice makers increase a refrigerator’s energy consumption significantly? 

Ice makers do increase energy consumption slightly, typically adding about 10-20% to a refrigerator’s electricity usage. However, ENERGY STAR certified models like those we’ve reviewed are designed to minimize this impact, often offsetting the increase through more efficient overall operation.

What’s the difference between crescent-shaped ice from the Kenmore models versus the ice from other refrigerators?

 Crescent-shaped ice cubes, like those produced by the Kenmore models, offer quick cooling due to their increased surface area compared to traditional cube shapes. They also tend to slide into glasses more easily without splashing and stack efficiently in the ice bin. The other models typically produce standard rectangular or cylindrical ice cubes, which may melt slightly slower but serve essentially the same purpose.

Conclusion

After thoroughly examining the top refrigerators with ice makers available today, it’s clear that each offers unique advantages depending on your specific needs and preferences.

For families seeking maximum storage and reliable ice production, the Commercial Cool 20 Cu. Ft. or BLACK+DECKER 20.1 Cu. Ft. top mount models provide excellent value and performance. Those prioritizing interior organization and produce freshness might prefer the Kenmore 33 in. models with their humidity-controlled crispers and adjustable shelving. And for design-conscious consumers with space constraints, the BLACK+DECKER 16 Cu. Ft. French Door refrigerator offers elegant styling and efficient use of space.

All five models provide the convenience of automatic ice production, eliminating the hassle of ice trays while ensuring you always have ice when you need it. With daily production ranging from 3 to 3.5 pounds, these refrigerators can meet the needs of most households while maintaining energy efficiency through their ENERGY STAR certification.

When making your final decision, consider not just the refrigerator itself but how it will fit into your lifestyle. The right refrigerator with ice maker won’t just keep your food fresh and your beverages cold—it will enhance your daily routine and entertaining capabilities for years to come.